Scott 1st 2023 Mock

[Scott4Pack]

Here’s my first mock this year, showing a trade of Rodgers for NYJ #43.

pff_mock_results.png (502.02 KiB) Viewed 530 times

[Scott4Pack]

I didn’t pay for the “pro” info. So, to be honest, I don’t know a lot about these guys. But I wanted to get a mock out there sooner than later.

I wanted a good receiving target for the RZ and third downs, so I went with a TE. Kincaid isn’t actually my first pick. I’d love us to get the guy from Norte Dame, but he wasn’t available in the mock (already taken). But Kincaid is good and should be Love’s security blanket.

Smith is an interior guy and we do need help there.

The trade for Rodgers will not yield a 1st, in my view. (Hope that I’m wrong.)

Adebawore is an edge guy. I want an edge picked high, but I really don’t know much about him.

Williams seems to be speedy enough, if raw. He will fit in nicely and have time to develop.

Wypler is a Big10 guy and helps the competitive nature of our Center position that is needed.

McGuire is another edge guy. But he can fill in at ST. And maybe we can get a few snaps in the Edge rotation meanwhile.

Kuntz might be a ST guy for a time. But we will find, with a new starting QB, that we cannot have enough TEs. And “Kuntz” is a good name for a Packer!

O’Connell fit in round 5. He will be talented enough if Love goes down. And he might become good enough to start (on a different team) someday.

Winters is another good name for a Packer. Put him on ST for a season. Same for Miller.

Shorter might actually turn into something. And in round 7, that’s okay if it takes time.

Luepke is another great Packer name. Watson would’ve put in a word for this guy.

Hill is another developmental guy.

[YoHoChecko]

Some good names, some good positions. I sort of hate Dalton Kincaid because he's old and his athleticism is average, but he's an immediate big slot receiving threat while he learns to block, if he does, and other nuances of the game

Very interesting array of front 7 defenders. Adeboware was thought to be an edge/3-tech 'tweener and then just blew the doors off the combine athletically. So is he a big edge? A small 3-tech? Both? A 4-3 DE only? I love the player; am unsure about the fit with the Packers. BUT getting a BIG athletic DT, an uber-athletic inside/outside guy and the McGuire, more of a power rusher in the mold of Enegbare or Za'Darius developmentally, certainly gives us reinforcements and options all around the DL. Don't know anything about the LB you picked.

Glad you gave us a FB type. I feel like we may add one.

Not a big fan of Shorter, even though he's taller; gotta have big WR in there somewhere, though. Would like more of a quick separator.

I love Kuntz and he'll take a ton of development. But don't love adding two TEs that don't really block (yet).

All in all, a really fun addition. Our defensive coaches would have a really fun time with these pieces.

[BF004]

Not a big fan of Shorter, even though he's taller;

[Packfntk]

Great mock, and these are fun. I love your edge and overall defensive options. I would be kind of mad if he went TE in the 1st though. I mean, it would be a little sexy because there are a couple nice options, just not my cup of tea. They take 3-4 years to fully develop, I’d rather get a decent TE off the FA heap and let the others invest high draft capital in them.

[AmishMafia]

Well PFF liked it - you got mostly A's. I usually get a few D's.

Like the idea of building our Dline. I think we need more help for the Oline though.

Not familiar with a bunch of these guys so I can't say much.

[Labrev]

I have come around to Kincaid in 1. 'Not my first choice but I can get behind it without any real issue. Draftniks whose opinion I trust think he will be a legit playmaker at the next level, and that he is not just winning on superior athleticism next to college comp but is already very refined and nuanced in his receiving skills.

I would like to see pro day numbers to confirm he has the requisite athleticism, especially with all these other TEs testing really well, but I am willing to trust tape judgment.

I like Mazi Smith a lot as a Round 2 DL target, and a freak like Adebawore paired next to Gary is a fun thought if we can coach him up. With Preston back in the fold, I am willing to take a less pro-ready guy at EDGE. Wypler sounds like a pure C. I don't overly mind the pick with Myers being a question mark but I would prefer someone who can play G if Myers figures it out this season.

I'm okay with Kuntz there. Don't know any of the other guys, the positions largely check out although I wouldn't bother with a FB. If we really need that then stick Deguara or one of the other TEs there. Solid mock.

[Scott4Pack]

Some good names, some good positions. I sort of hate Dalton Kincaid because he's old and his athleticism is average, but he's an immediate big slot receiving threat while he learns to block, if he does, and other nuances of the game

Very interesting array of front 7 defenders. Adeboware was thought to be an edge/3-tech 'tweener and then just blew the doors off the combine athletically. So is he a big edge? A small 3-tech? Both? A 4-3 DE only? I love the player; am unsure about the fit with the Packers. BUT getting a BIG athletic DT, an uber-athletic inside/outside guy and the McGuire, more of a power rusher in the mold of Enegbare or Za'Darius developmentally, certainly gives us reinforcements and options all around the DL. Don't know anything about the LB you picked.

Glad you gave us a FB type. I feel like we may add one.

Not a big fan of Shorter, even though he's taller; gotta have big WR in there somewhere, though. Would like more of a quick separator.

I love Kuntz and he'll take a ton of development. But don't love adding two TEs that don't really block (yet).

All in all, a really fun addition. Our defensive coaches would have a really fun time with these pieces.

I did this more for the going through the motions of it, without really analyzing the players and how they fit (or don’t fit). I’ll do another later with more consideration. But I did glean how complicated it can be for any GM to see what players are available when the pick comes up and how frustrating it can be to have to try to trade down or choose a player that isn’t as high as you’d like on your team’s board.

[Scott4Pack]

Great mock, and these are fun. I love your edge and overall defensive options. I would be kind of mad if he went TE in the 1st though. I mean, it would be a little sexy because there are a couple nice options, just not my cup of tea. They take 3-4 years to fully develop, I’d rather get a decent TE off the FA heap and let the others invest high draft capital in them.

I know how you feel. I’d really like to take that TE from Notre Dame and it’ll take a 1st to get him. He mimics Whitten. And who wouldn’t want a guy like that!
:-)

[Scott4Pack]

Well PFF liked it - you got mostly A's. I usually get a few D's.

Like the idea of building our Dline. I think we need more help for the Oline though.

Not familiar with a bunch of these guys so I can't say much.

Yeah. I really doubt the Packers go very long before drafting a OLine guy. But after the 1st round, they just weren’t popping up for me, at least not any that had value for the pick. Argh!

[Packfntk]

Great mock, and these are fun. I love your edge and overall defensive options. I would be kind of mad if he went TE in the 1st though. I mean, it would be a little sexy because there are a couple nice options, just not my cup of tea. They take 3-4 years to fully develop, I’d rather get a decent TE off the FA heap and let the others invest high draft capital in them.

I know how you feel. I’d really like to take that TE from Notre Dame and it’ll take a 1st to get him. He mimics Whitten. And who wouldn’t want a guy like that!
:-)

Yep, he’s my favorite TE in the draft. Would be incredible to have that guy, but what you are giving up to draft him there may be too much IMO.

[Pugger]

Kincaid is the only TE worth a first round pick. Would he be the BPA at that spot? I don't know but perhaps you guys do.

[Scott4Pack]

Kincaid is the only TE worth a first round pick. Would he be the BPA at that spot? I don't know but perhaps you guys do.

He is talented, for sure. But he has two things that might go against him. First, he is old and isn’t a 22 year old or so. Second, he doesn’t block well. That’ll almost certainly cross him off of Guty’s list. But as I ran the mock, I wanted to get a TE in that slot. Hahaha.

[Pugger]

Kincaid is the only TE worth a first round pick. Would he be the BPA at that spot? I don't know but perhaps you guys do.

He is talented, for sure. But he has two things that might go against him. First, he is old and isn’t a 22 year old or so. Second, he doesn’t block well. That’ll almost certainly cross him off of Guty’s list. But as I ran the mock, I wanted to get a TE in that slot. Hahaha.

How old is he?

[Scott4Pack]

Kincaid is the only TE worth a first round pick. Would he be the BPA at that spot? I don't know but perhaps you guys do.

He is talented, for sure. But he has two things that might go against him. First, he is old and isn’t a 22 year old or so. Second, he doesn’t block well. That’ll almost certainly cross him off of Guty’s list. But as I ran the mock, I wanted to get a TE in that slot. Hahaha.

How old is he?

I believe he is 25, but should double-check.