Packers @ Giants GDT: Monday, Dec. 11th, 7:15 PM CST

[lupedafiasco]

Frustration challenge by LaFleur. Things not going his way and he panics.

[NCF]

Giants get the ball in the 3rd, so not giving up a long drive here would be nice. So far, so not good.

[Drj820]

Guess refs not calling holding tonight

[YoHoChecko]

How do we not have a more competent review process?

We even got a see a replay on TV that saw it was a catch before the next snap. Telling me you don’t got a team of guys in the booth watching every angle with headsets directly to LaFleur?

Guys. Look at the replay. MLF is staring directly at the play. He wasn't baited; our system didn't fail him.

MLF personally thought he saw the ball bobble when Robinson took his first hand off of it. He was STARING at the play. That was his red flag and his alone. It wasn't the result of anything other than his own eyes failing him--or his brain's interpretation of it.

Why does everything have to be something bigger?

[NCF]

How do we not have a more competent review process?

We even got a see a replay on TV that saw it was a catch before the next snap. Telling me you don’t got a team of guys in the booth watching every angle with headsets directly to LaFleur?

Guys. Look at the replay. MLF is staring directly at the play. He wasn't baited; our system didn't fail him.

MLF personally thought he saw the ball bobble when Robinson took his first hand off of it. He was STARING at the play. That was his red flag and his alone. It wasn't the result of anything other than his own eyes failing him--or his brain's interpretation of it.

Why does everything have to be something bigger?

You have the ability to confirm via video, you do it. No one told him it was a bobble because it wasn’t, so I don’t care what he thinks he saw.

[go pak go]

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Crazylegs Starks]

Preston, Wilson, and McDuffie did good!

[BF004]

How do we not have a more competent review process?

We even got a see a replay on TV that saw it was a catch before the next snap. Telling me you don’t got a team of guys in the booth watching every angle with headsets directly to LaFleur?

Guys. Look at the replay. MLF is staring directly at the play. He wasn't baited; our system didn't fail him.

MLF personally thought he saw the ball bobble when Robinson took his first hand off of it. He was STARING at the play. That was his red flag and his alone. It wasn't the result of anything other than his own eyes failing him--or his brain's interpretation of it.

Why does everything have to be something bigger?

So yes, maybe we shouldn’t rely on someone’s eyes on the sideline when you can have guys in the booth with slow mo and multiple angles. I don’t like that process. So I guess it’s something bigger?

[Drj820]

That was a formation from the 1940s. Nice

[Cdragon]

Great stop! C'mon O!

[Pckfn23]

Nice Stop!

[NCF]

Horrible run D, horrible run offense, pitiful short yardage run offense, but somehow unbelievably awesome short yardage run D.

[BF004]

Woof.

Slow developing sweep with pulling linemen on a 4th and 1.

Don’t think this lot would be very happy about that call.

[Drj820]

How do we not have a more competent review process?

We even got a see a replay on TV that saw it was a catch before the next snap. Telling me you don’t got a team of guys in the booth watching every angle with headsets directly to LaFleur?

Guys. Look at the replay. MLF is staring directly at the play. He wasn't baited; our system didn't fail him.

MLF personally thought he saw the ball bobble when Robinson took his first hand off of it. He was STARING at the play. That was his red flag and his alone. It wasn't the result of anything other than his own eyes failing him--or his brain's interpretation of it.

Why does everything have to be something bigger?

Are you on your period again? It’s my opinion the way the receiver ran like he wanted to hurry up the next play affected the decision to hurry up and challenge. If you disagree that’s cool but no one is making anything a scandal

[lulu]

Frustration challenge by LaFleur. Things not going his way and he panics.

Reminded me of a McCarthy challenge.

[YoHoChecko]

You have the ability to confirm via video, you do it. No one told him it was a bobble because it wasn’t, so I don’t care what he thinks he saw.

I'm not saying it wasn't a bad challenge or his mistake.

I;m saying it's dumb how everyone jumped in here to come up with some reason to make it more than it was. Oh, he got fooled by the opposition. Oh, the Packer's coaching booth should have caught that. I bet they did. MLF challenged that play right away. He didn't check. He didn't think he needed to. Because the guy who makes the decision was WATCHING with as good of an angle as anyone.

He made a bad challenge. But it wasn't like some big stupid anything.

This is why I always wind up quitting gameday threads for half the season. Everyone is arguing about dumb things (myself included) mid-game


EDIT:

see?

Are you on your period again? It’s my opinion the way the receiver ran like he wanted to hurry up the next play affected the decision to hurry up and challenge. If you disagree that’s cool but no one is making anything a scandal

[Drj820]

You have the ability to confirm via video, you do it. No one told him it was a bobble because it wasn’t, so I don’t care what he thinks he saw.

I'm not saying it wasn't a bad challenge or his mistake.

I;m saying it's dumb how everyone jumped in here to come up with some reason to make it more than it was. Oh, he got fooled by the opposition. Oh, the Packer's coaching booth should have caught that. I bet they did. MLF challenged that play right away. He didn't check. He didn't think he needed to. Because the guy who makes the decision was WATCHING with as good of an angle as anyone.

He made a bad challenge. But it wasn't like some big stupid anything.

This is why I always wind up quitting gameday threads for half the season. Everyone is arguing about dumb things (myself included) mid-game

We just talking man. I think he didn’t wait due to receivers reaction.

[NCF]

Nothing good about that decision.

[Drj820]

Ooof

[go pak go]

Zach Tom is getting his ass kicked tonight.