Rank the Roster: 2014-2019

[Waldo]

This thread is for historical Rank the Roster rankings from the old site.

[Waldo]

Rank The Roster: 2014 Edition

1. Aaron Rodgers (97%)
2. Clay Matthews (81%)
3. Josh Sitton (45%)
4. Jordy Nelson (50%)
5. Eddie Lacy (60%)
6. Sam Shields (38%)
7. Julius Peppers (48%)
8. Randall Cobb (45%)
9. Mike Daniels (61%)
10. Tramon Williams (58%)
11. Brian Bulaga (56%)
12. AJ Hawk (54%)
13. TJ Lang (42%)
14. Casey Hayward (68%)
15. David Bakhtiari (37%)
16. Morgan Burnett (48%)
17. BJ Raji (48%)
18. Nick Perry (56%)
19. Mike Neal (40%)
20. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix (31%)
21. James Starks (27%)
22. Datone Jones (40%)
23. JC Tretter (33%)
24. Micah Hyde (37%)
25. Jarrett Boykin (41%)
26. Brad Jones (39%)
27. Josh Boyd (59%)
28. Don Barclay (33%)
29. Mason Crosby (29%)
30. Davante Adams (30%)
31. Andrew Quarless (43%)
32. Derrick Sherrod (35%)
33. Davon House (30%)
34. DuJuan Harris (31%)
35. Matt Flynn (31%)
36. Jamari Lattimore (46%)
37. Brandon $%&# (48%)
38. John Kuhn (33%)
39. Jarrett Bush (50%)
40. Tim Masthay (44%)
41. Jerel Worthy (48%)
42. Richard Rodgers (68%)
43. Sean Richardson (45%)
44. Khyri Thornton (42%)

[Waldo]

Rank The Roster: 2015 Edition

1. Aaron Rodgers (100%)[nc]
2. Clay Matthews (79%)[nc]
3. Josh Sitton (43%)[nc]
4. Jordy Nelson (55%)[nc]
5. Eddie Lacy (40%)[nc]
6. Julius Peppers (48%)[+1]
7. Randall Cobb (56%)[+1]
8. Mike Daniels (77%)[+1]
9. Sam Shields (38%)[-3]
10. Brian Bulaga (81%)[+1]
11. TJ Lang (71%)[+2]
12. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix (54%)[+8]
13. Corey Linsley (42%)[+32]
14. David Bakhtiari (48%)[+1]
15. Casey Hayward (43%)[-1]
16. Morgan Burnett (81%)[nc]
17. BJ Raji (52%)[nc]
18. Nick Perry (29%)[nc]
19. Davante Adams (65%)[+11]
20. Richard Rodgers (36%)[+22]
21. Micah Hyde (41%)[+3]
22. Sam Barrington (77%)[+23]
23. Datone Jones (39%)[-1]
24. Damarious Randall (35%)[R]
25. Mike Neal (38%)[-6]
26. Letroy Guion (67%)[+19]
27. Don Barclay (42%)[+1]
28. James Starks (38%)[-7]
29. Andrew Quarless (41%)[+2]
30. Josh Boyd (43%)[-3]
31. Quinten Rollins (44%)[R]
32. Mason Crosby (54%)[-3]
33. Jake Ryan (38%)[R]
34. Ty Montgomery (45%)[R]
35. Jeff Janis (44%)[+10]
36. John Kuhn (41%)[+2]
37. Sean Richardson (40%)[+6]
38. Scott Tolzien (48%)[+7]
39. Jayrone Elliott (48%)[+6]
40. JC Tretter (45%)[-17]
41. Carl Bradford (45%)[+4]
42. Mike Pennel (65%)[+3]
43. Demetri Goodson (50%)[+2]
44. Rajion Neal (35%)[+1]
45. Aaron Ripkowsk (50%)[[R]]
46. Chris Banjo/Ladarius Gunter (32%, tie)

[Waldo]

Rank The Roster: 2016 Edition

1. Aaron Rodgers (96%)[--]
2. Clay Matthews (62%)[--]
3. Mike Daniels (54%)[+5]
4. Jordy Nelson (91%)[--]
5. Sam Shields (42%)[+4]
6. Josh Sitton (55%)[-3]
7. TJ Lang (72%)[+4]
8. Eddie Lacy (36%)[-3]
9. Julius Peppers (36%)[-3]
10. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix (44%)[+2]
11. Damarious Randall (46%)[+13]
12. Randall Cobb (68%)[-5]
13. Brian Bulaga (56%)[-3]
14. Morgan Burnett (46%)[+2]
15. Corey Linsley (57%)[-2]
16. David Bakhtiari (58%)[-2]
17. Jared Cook (26%)[FA]
18. Nick Perry (30%)[--]
19. Quinten Rollins (32%)[+12]
20. Davante Adams (38%)[-1]
21. Sam Barrington (38%)[+1]
22. Kenny Clark (43%)[R]
23. JC Tretter (40%)[+17]
24. Letroy Guion (41%)[+1]
25. Jake Ryan (39%)[+8]
26. Mason Crosby (36%)[+6]
27. James Starks (57%)[+1]
28. Datone Jones (33%)[-5]
29. Jeff Janis (38%)[+6]
30. Ty Montgomery (30%)[+4]
31. Micah Hyde (45%)[-10]
32. Richard Rodgers (32%)[-12]
33. Aaron Ripkowski (33%)[+12]
34. Mile Pennel (40%)[+8]
35. Jason Spriggs (29%)[R]
36. Blake Martinez (35%)[R]
37. Jayrone Elliott (41%)[+2]
38. Brett Hundley (48%)[+9]
39. Ladarius Gunter (75%)[+7]
40. Christian Ringo (32%)[+7]
41. Kyler Fackrell (43%)[R]
42. Chris Banjo (39%)[+4]
43. Mitchell Henry (29%)[+5]
44. Dean Lowry (40%)[R]
45. Trevor Davis (45%)[R]

[Waldo]

Rank The Roster: 2017 Edition

1. Aaron Rodgers (95%)[--]
2. David Bakhtiari (42%)[+14]
3. Mike Daniels (48%)[--]
4. Jordy Nelson (54%)[--]
5. Clay Matthews (37%)[-3]
6. Nick Perry (52%)[+12]
7. Martellus Bennett (52%)[FA]
8. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix (52%)[+2]
9. Brian Bulaga (43%)[+4]
10. Davante Adams (55%)[+10]
11. Morgan Burnett (56%)[+3]
12. Ty Montgomery (46%)[+18]
13. Corey Linsley (68%)[+2]
14. Randall Cobb (71%)[-2]
15. Kenny Clark (83%)[+7]
16. Lane Taylor (39%)[+30]
17. Damarious Randall (43%)[-6]
18. Jake Ryan (30%)[+7]
19. Blake Martinez (43%)[+17]
20. Davon House (75%)[FA]
21. Kevin King (54%)[R]
22. Jahri Evans (54%)[FA]
23. Jamaal Williams (30%)[R]
24. Josh Jones (30%)[R]
25. Kyler Fackrell (35%)[+16]
26. Aaron Ripkowski (38%)[+7]
27. Jason Spriggs (30%)[+8]
28. Mason Crosby (37%)[-2]
29. Quinten Rollins (40%)[-10]
30. Ricky Jean Francois (36%)[FA]
31. Dean Lowry (45%)[+13]
32. Lance Kendricks (36%)[FA]
33. Brett Hundley (50%)[+5]
34. Joe Thomas (28%)[+12]
35. Ladarius Gunter (35%)[+4]
36. Kentrell Brice (40%)[+10]
37. Aaron Jones (24%)[R]
38. Jayrone Elliott (29%)[-1]
39. Montravius Adams (40%)[R]
40. Trevor Davis (30%)[+5]
41. Richard Rodgers/Kyle Murphy (35%, tie)

[Waldo]

Rank The Roster: 2018 Edition

1. Aaron Rodgers (96%)[--]
2. David Bakhtiari (88%)[--]
3. Davante Adams (35%)[+7]
4. Mike Daniels (43%)[-1]
5. Kenny Clark (68%)[+10]
6. Clay Matthews (56%)[-1]
7. Jimmy Graham (40%)[FA]
8. Blake Martinez (54%)[+11]
9. Nick Perry (41%)[-3]
10. Muhammad Wilkerson (33%)[FA]
11. Randall Cobb (39%)[+3]
12. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix (41%)[-4]
13. Bryan Bulaga (48%)[-4]
14. Aaron Jones (31%)[+23]
15. Kevin King (51%)[+6]
16. Jaire Alexander (42%)[R]
17. Lane Taylor (42%)[-1]
18. Tramon Williams (46%)[FA]
19. Corey Linsley (46%)[-6]
20. Josh Jones (65%)[+4]
21. Justin McCray (40%)[+22]
22. Ty Montgomery (44%)[-10]
23. Marcedes Lewis (42%)[FA]
24. Jake Ryan (37%)[-6]
25. Dean Lowry (32%)[+6]
26. Jamaal Williams (39%)[-3]
27. Kentrell Brice (46%)[+9]
28. Josh Jackson (43%)[R]
29. Mason Crosby (52%)[-1]
30. Vince Biegel (39%)[+13]
31. J'Mon Moore (45%)[R]
32. Kyle Murphy (37%)[+9]
33. Oren Burks (45%)[R]
34. Jason Spriggs (43%)[-7]
35. Aaron Ripkowski (32%)[-9]
36. DeShone Kizer (30%)[T]
37. Cole Madison (32%)[R]
38. Montravius Adams (35%)[+1]
39. Davon House (35%)[-19]
40. Reggie Gilbert (32%)[+2]
41. Trevor Davis (40%)[-1]
42. Geronimo Allison (32%)[--]
43. Kyler Fackrell (30%)[-18]
44. Lance Kendricks (39%)[-12]
45. Equanimeous St. Brown (33%)[R]
46. Lenzy Pipkins (40%)[R]

[Waldo]

Rank The Roster: 2019 Edition

1. Aaron Rodgers (90%)[--]
2. David Bakhtiari (78%)[--]
3. Kenny Clark (59%)[+2]
4. Davante Adams (100%)[-1]
5. Jaire Alexander (57%)[+11]
6. Aaron Jones (62%)[+8]
7. Za'Darius Smith (45%)[FA]
8. Brian Bulaga (52%)[+5]
9. Blake Martinez (68%)[-1]
10. Adrian Amos (46%)[FA]
11. Corey Linsley (52%)[+8]
12. Mike Daniels (55%)[-1]
13. Preston Smith (76%)[FA]
14. Kevin King (48%)[+1]
15. Jimmy Graham (36%)[-8]
16. Darnell Savage (50%)[R]
17. Marquez Valdes-Scantling (57%)[+29]
18. Billy Turner (45%)[FA]
19. Equanimeous St. Brown (35%)[+26]
20. Rashan Gary (62%)[R]
21. Josh Jackson (41%)[+7]
22. Dean Lowry (30%)[+3]
23. Jamaal Williams (41%)[+3]
24. Elgton Jenkins (57%)[R]
25. Tramon Williams (50%)[-7]
26. Geronimo Allison (62%)[+16]
27. Kyler Fackrell (52%)[+16]
28. Lane Taylor (50%)[-11]
29. Oren Burks (38%)[+4]
30. Trevor Davis (53%)[+11]
31. Tyler Lancaster (56%)[+16]
32. Jace Sternberger (32%)[R]
33. Raven Greene (29%)[+14]
34. Dexter Williams (40%)[R]
35. Mason Crosby (53%)[-6]
36. Marcedes Lewis (29%)[-6]
37. Robert Tonyan (39%)[+10]
38. James Crawford (41%)[+9]
39. Montravious Adams (47%)[-1]
40. Tony Brown (46%)[WW]
41. Jake Kumerow (43%)[+6]
42. Jason Spriggs (47%)[-8]
43. DeShone Kizer (35%)[-7]
43. Kingsley Keke/Ka'Dar Hollman (20%, tie)

[Waldo]

Percent of vote the winner got will be in parenthesis, position change vs. 2018 will be in brackets.

Here's how this works:

Each day there is a new thread/poll, starting at #1, on down to whereever we get. The whole point of this exercise is to have something to talk about in the lean news months to carry us to camp. Each poll will be open for voting for 24 hours. New threads will only be created on weekdays. Ties will cause a runoff poll.

Simply voting is not enough!

Post why you voted for who you did and provide a player to add to the next poll (every poll will be a list of 10 guys, a new player is added to the list each day).

Here's the thing. There is no criteria. This is an exercise to foster discussion therefore there are no clear criteria for ranking. Who is better right now? Who will have the best season? Who was better last year? Sort of a combo of them all? Do you take positional value into account? It really doesn't matter.

Previous Years:

[TheGreenMan]

Interesting to go back and see how our voting turned out. Linsey appears to have had the biggest jump (32+).. another offensive linemen behind him, Lane Taylor (30+).

It's crazy how high MVS and Brown jumped up, they're going to plummet this go around.