Page 2 of 3

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 13:55
by kampmanfan4life
Reed's end around sure was fun to watch

Alex McGough I think it is at the end doing up downs, man he does them twice as fast as everyone else. Probably just more energy then everyone else.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 13:55
by Scott4Pack
Pckfn23 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 10:17
I have very high expectations for Nixon this year!

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 14:02
by wallyuwl
Scott4Pack wrote:
27 Jul 2023 13:55
Pckfn23 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 10:17
I have very high expectations for Nixon this year!
Wouldn't surprise me at all if he is a starting safety by week 5.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 14:55
by Yoop
wallyuwl wrote:
27 Jul 2023 14:02
Scott4Pack wrote:
27 Jul 2023 13:55
Pckfn23 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 10:17
I have very high expectations for Nixon this year!
Wouldn't surprise me at all if he is a starting safety by week 5.
I think Nixon will be our #1 kick returner, so I don't expect to see him as a starting defender, what makes a returner great is fresh legs, wear them down and the drop off can be dramatic :dunno:

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 16:10
by Labrev
Sounds like Jayden Reed was killing it out there today! :)

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 16:18
by APB
Two days in and I think I've seen Toure's name in a two tweets. Reed, otoh, has been mentioned a ton.

Looks the the Rank the Roster crowd who argued Reed over Toure may have nailed it.

Speaking of which, has the WR pecking order been mentioned? Are they all swapping out randomly?

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 16:26
by Labrev
APB wrote:
27 Jul 2023 16:18
Two days in and I think I've seen Toure's name in a two tweets. Reed, otoh, has been mentioned a ton.

Looks the the Rank the Roster crowd who argued Reed over Toure may have nailed it.

Speaking of which, has the WR pecking order been mentioned? Are they all swapping out randomly?
Toure actually had a nice day yesterday, got very open a few times and had a really nice reception on the last play. I think he will still see the field a lot, even if Reed is ahead of him, as seems to be the case.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 17:03
by Yoop
APB wrote:
27 Jul 2023 16:18
Two days in and I think I've seen Toure's name in a two tweets. Reed, otoh, has been mentioned a ton.

Looks the the Rank the Roster crowd who argued Reed over Toure may have nailed it.

Speaking of which, has the WR pecking order been mentioned? Are they all swapping out randomly?
I loved what Tae Adams was able to do, but our receiver situation is vastly better, having 2 receivers that are legitimate #2' guys to couple with a dominate #1 which most of us think Watson can be is so much better then Adams and a bunch of #3 or 4's for depth.
Watson, Reed, Doubs, Toure, Wicks, even as young as they are we'll probably have the premier receiver group in the North and possible even the NFC

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 17:10
by BF004


Show me, don’t tell me

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 17:46
by lupedafiasco
APB wrote:
27 Jul 2023 16:18
Two days in and I think I've seen Toure's name in a two tweets. Reed, otoh, has been mentioned a ton.

Looks the the Rank the Roster crowd who argued Reed over Toure may have nailed it.

Speaking of which, has the WR pecking order been mentioned? Are they all swapping out randomly?
Who would have thought the 2nd round pick is better than the 7th. Weird game.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 18:06
by BF004
lupedafiasco wrote:
27 Jul 2023 17:46
APB wrote:
27 Jul 2023 16:18
Two days in and I think I've seen Toure's name in a two tweets. Reed, otoh, has been mentioned a ton.

Looks the the Rank the Roster crowd who argued Reed over Toure may have nailed it.

Speaking of which, has the WR pecking order been mentioned? Are they all swapping out randomly?
Who would have thought the 2nd round pick is better than the 7th. Weird game.
image.png
image.png (1.35 MiB) Viewed 441 times

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 18:35
by Labrev
Well apart from examples like that, where the rebuttal will just be (correctly) that cases like that are the exception to the rule, I would cite Amari Rodgers, where we though for sure that a guy we drafted in Day 2 would leapfrog our late-round "Stooges" at WR in no time, only to cut him midway through his second year. And he was considered a pretty pro-ready, plug-and-play prospect.

Yes, the expectation is always that the high draft picks will be better. Nobody disputed the logic of that. The only real question was if he will be a rookie that "gets it" right away, or if the game proves to be too big for him. There's no way to know that until they play.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 19:39
by lupedafiasco
BF004 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 18:06
lupedafiasco wrote:
27 Jul 2023 17:46
APB wrote:
27 Jul 2023 16:18
Two days in and I think I've seen Toure's name in a two tweets. Reed, otoh, has been mentioned a ton.

Looks the the Rank the Roster crowd who argued Reed over Toure may have nailed it.

Speaking of which, has the WR pecking order been mentioned? Are they all swapping out randomly?
Who would have thought the 2nd round pick is better than the 7th. Weird game.
image.png
Oddly enough I called that one. Flynn was a winner and Brohm had not a single special attribute.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 21:57
by Pckfn23
:hide:

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 22:11
by wallyuwl

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 27 Jul 2023 22:27
by Drj820
lupedafiasco wrote:
27 Jul 2023 19:39
BF004 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 18:06
lupedafiasco wrote:
27 Jul 2023 17:46


Who would have thought the 2nd round pick is better than the 7th. Weird game.
image.png
Oddly enough I called that one. Flynn was a winner and Brohm had not a single special attribute.
Is it frustrating to make a valid point and have anomaly’s mentioned as if they should invalidate your solid take?

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 28 Jul 2023 03:08
by CWIMM
Labrev wrote:
27 Jul 2023 11:46
Pckfn23 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 11:28
Blegh... I hate our IOL depth.
Myers improving over his performance last year would go a long way in improving the depth on the interior offensive line. Don't forget that Tom can line up there if needed as well.
wallyuwl wrote:
27 Jul 2023 14:02
Wouldn't surprise me at all if he is a starting safety by week 5.
I don't think the Packers have any plans of moving Nixon to safety.
Yoop wrote:
27 Jul 2023 17:03
I loved what Tae Adams was able to do, but our receiver situation is vastly better, having 2 receivers that are legitimate #2' guys to couple with a dominate #1 which most of us think Watson can be is so much better then Adams and a bunch of #3 or 4's for depth.
Watson, Reed, Doubs, Toure, Wicks, even as young as they are we'll probably have the premier receiver group in the North and possible even the NFC
Watson needs to prove he's truly a legit #1 receiver. The same is true for Doubs and Reed as #2s as well. Therefore I don't consider the receiving corps to be any better than it was while Adams was still around at this point.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 28 Jul 2023 05:45
by APB
Drj820 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 22:27
lupedafiasco wrote:
27 Jul 2023 19:39
BF004 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 18:06

image.png
Oddly enough I called that one. Flynn was a winner and Brohm had not a single special attribute.
Is it frustrating to make a valid point and have anomaly’s mentioned as if they should invalidate your solid take?
If the discussion in the Rank the Roster thread consisted solely of draft position, it'd be a solid take. It didn't.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 28 Jul 2023 07:44
by Yoop
CWIMM wrote:
28 Jul 2023 03:08
Labrev wrote:
27 Jul 2023 11:46
Pckfn23 wrote:
27 Jul 2023 11:28
Blegh... I hate our IOL depth.
Myers improving over his performance last year would go a long way in improving the depth on the interior offensive line. Don't forget that Tom can line up there if needed as well.
wallyuwl wrote:
27 Jul 2023 14:02
Wouldn't surprise me at all if he is a starting safety by week 5.
I don't think the Packers have any plans of moving Nixon to safety.
Yoop wrote:
27 Jul 2023 17:03
I loved what Tae Adams was able to do, but our receiver situation is vastly better, having 2 receivers that are legitimate #2' guys to couple with a dominate #1 which most of us think Watson can be is so much better then Adams and a bunch of #3 or 4's for depth.
Watson, Reed, Doubs, Toure, Wicks, even as young as they are we'll probably have the premier receiver group in the North and possible even the NFC
Watson needs to prove he's truly a legit #1 receiver. The same is true for Doubs and Reed as #2s as well. Therefore I don't consider the receiving corps to be any better than it was while Adams was still around at this point.
Watson proved that to me last year, heck so did Doubs.

Re: 2023 Training Camp - 7/27

Posted: 28 Jul 2023 08:05
by Labrev
Also (related), I thought 7th-rounder Isaiah McDuffie outplayed our Round 1 pick at the same position last year, and that Quay only got the nod over him due to "politics."


So also, Love had a nice day, made lots of nice plays, only negative was the INT and it was more of a great Jaire play than a bad decision by QB1.