Page 2 of 2

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 06 Sep 2024 20:10
by RingoCStarrQB
Cdragon wrote:
06 Sep 2024 18:19
Inactives

WR Malik Heath
RB MarShawn Lloyd
DL Arron Mosby
DL Brenton Cox Jr.
T Kadeem Telfort
T Travis Glover
I barely know who these guys are.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 06 Sep 2024 22:50
by Crazylegs Starks
Reed wins this week

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 06 Sep 2024 23:06
by lupedafiasco
Reed won easily. Had a 3rd TD that was called back. A legit call but his effort even in that play showed he was one of the few players on the field that felt losing was not an option. Untackleable.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 07 Sep 2024 06:40
by Cdragon
For your consideration.
Wicks - Packfntk
Brayden Narveson - RingoCStarrQB
Musgrave - Cdragon
Jacobs - Lupedafiacso
Watson – Madcity_Matt
Romeo – Pckfn23
Alexander – Yoop
Quay Walker - Labrev
Jayden Reed - mnkcarp
X McKinney – Drj820
Jordan Love - APB
Stokes – go_pak_go
Rashan Gary – Crazylegs_Starks
Kenny Clark - NCF
Kraft – BF004
Bullard - YoHoChecko
Wyatt - AmishMafia

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 07 Sep 2024 07:15
by Labrev
Reed

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 07 Sep 2024 09:17
by NCF
APB wrote:
06 Sep 2024 11:49
Shoot, I'll be that guy.

Jordan Love
Image

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 07 Sep 2024 11:11
by AmishMafia
Reed

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 07 Sep 2024 11:25
by APB
NCF wrote:
07 Sep 2024 09:17
APB wrote:
06 Sep 2024 11:49
Shoot, I'll be that guy.

Jordan Love
Image
:lol:

Don't think that hasn't crossed my mind...

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 08 Sep 2024 15:43
by TheSkeptic
Zach Tom lead all Packers in the pff ratings. However Walker and Myers had &%$@ games and so the Oline as a whole does not deserve a vote.

Get rid of the Oline vote possibility. Tom gets my vote but of course no one picked him

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 08 Sep 2024 21:16
by Cdragon
TheSkeptic wrote:
08 Sep 2024 15:43
Zach Tom lead all Packers in the pff ratings. However Walker and Myers had &%$@ games and so the Oline as a whole does not deserve a vote.

Get rid of the Oline vote possibility. Tom gets my vote but of course no one picked him
you can still pick individual OL even if the OL as a whole is chosen.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 09 Sep 2024 10:51
by Yoop
TheSkeptic wrote:
08 Sep 2024 15:43
Zach Tom lead all Packers in the pff ratings. However Walker and Myers had &%$@ games and so the Oline as a whole does not deserve a vote.

Get rid of the Oline vote possibility. Tom gets my vote but of course no one picked him
so now we wait for PFF grades to pick the winner, no longer using personal observation, which obviously would show case Reed.

I still question some of PFF OL grades, and I seldom question what I myself see, and Reed was the MVP of that game, he'd have had another score minus a OL holding call.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 09 Sep 2024 14:30
by musclestang
I said last year we had 3 Oline positions we could upgrade. SOunds like we got one and unfortunately so far have holes at the 2 most important Oline positions in C and LT.

Anyway, I vote Reed. Clear winner to me.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 09 Sep 2024 19:11
by Cdragon
Reed looks like the runaway.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 09 Sep 2024 19:14
by Cdragon
musclestang wrote:
09 Sep 2024 14:30
I said last year we had 3 Oline positions we could upgrade. SOunds like we got one and unfortunately so far have holes at the 2 most important Oline positions in C and LT.

Anyway, I vote Reed. Clear winner to me.
I think part of the problem with LT was the NFL forcing these guys up on the line. They are going to get some QB killed. Walker will look better once they ease up, probably 3rd week.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 10 Sep 2024 06:22
by APB
I already voted for Reed but must admit, I was reluctant. His performance was standout, sure, but it wasn't an underdog showing by any means. That is, after all, the basis for this contest, isn't it? Yeah, Reed exceeded expectations but the better argument for me voting for him was the total lack of other candidates I saw immediately following the game.

I am half tempted to change my vote to Cooper now that I've seen the film breakdowns. In his limited snaps, he balled out. Didn't see that coming game one. Oh, nobody selected him.

Bullard should also get some consideration, IMO. He played solid ball, was aggressive, and brought a toughness attitude this defense sorely lacks.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 10 Sep 2024 07:48
by Cdragon
APB wrote:
10 Sep 2024 06:22
I already voted for Reed but must admit, I was reluctant. His performance was standout, sure, but it wasn't an underdog showing by any means. That is, after all, the basis for this contest, isn't it? Yeah, Reed exceeded expectations but the better argument for me voting for him was the total lack of other candidates I saw immediately following the game.

I am half tempted to change my vote to Cooper now that I've seen the film breakdowns. In his limited snaps, he balled out. Didn't see that coming game one. Oh, nobody selected him.

Bullard should also get some consideration, IMO. He played solid ball, was aggressive, and brought a toughness attitude this defense sorely lacks.

Right after the game I was thinking X though he also has the star label. Reed is a star but the fact that any receiver could be that days star, so it isn't quite like choosing Devante Adams, though it is riding one of the favorites.

Bullard had 7 tackles and 4 assists on his first day on the job. So that will be my vote.

Re: Here's Johnny Week 1 Death to Eagles!!!!

Posted: 11 Sep 2024 09:02
by Yoop
Yoop wrote:
09 Sep 2024 10:51
TheSkeptic wrote:
08 Sep 2024 15:43
Zach Tom lead all Packers in the pff ratings. However Walker and Myers had &%$@ games and so the Oline as a whole does not deserve a vote.

Get rid of the Oline vote possibility. Tom gets my vote but of course no one picked him
so now we wait for PFF grades to pick the winner, no longer using personal observation, which obviously would show case Reed.

I still question some of PFF OL grades, and I seldom question what I myself see, and Reed was the MVP of that game, he'd have had another score minus a OL holding call.
I'll correct myself, it was the 12 men on the field penalty that Reeds TD was called back

Herman thinks minus the poor footing and McKinny would have had 2 picks, he was Andy's highest graded defender, with Cooper and Bullard rounding out his top 3 on defense, Reed, Jenkins, Toms on offense.