Page 3 of 3
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 09:28
by paco
TheSkeptic wrote: ↑21 Jan 2024 03:51
BF004 wrote: ↑20 Jan 2024 21:18
I vote Erik Wilson
I agree. Wilson made an impossible play. Unfortunately no one picked him. So Robert Books who sacrificed a finger to deflect that kick.
Unlike TheSkeptic who clearly has a concussion and think Robert Brooks is still playing...
I'm voting for Karl Brooks. He had a solid game and the blocked kick could have been a back breaker and won us the game (had it not been for ineptitude in a lot of other areas).
I don't see anyone else who earns a vote over him.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 09:34
by go pak go
Pretty sure it was Colby Wooden who blocked the kick.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 11:22
by APB
go pak go wrote: ↑21 Jan 2024 09:34
Pretty sure it was Colby Wooden who blocked the kick.
Yes, I believe it was.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 11:31
by Yoop
APB wrote: ↑21 Jan 2024 11:22
go pak go wrote: ↑21 Jan 2024 09:34
Pretty sure it was Colby Wooden who blocked the kick.
Yes, I believe it was.
OH man, Colby could have won this thing, but no one picked him either
I always pick the wrong players
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 12:03
by Labrev
Offensive Line, I guess? No real egregious errors, did a nice job blocking for Aaron Jones against a front seven we have historically struggled to establish any kind of running game, let up a little pressure but to me more of a failure of Matt getting imbalanced and not running the ball enough, especially after having to sub Tom out with Nijman.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 12:12
by Crazylegs Starks
I'm thinking Doubs first, second O-line, and then Jaire for knocking out Deebo
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 12:16
by Labrev
Doubs dropped the TD and whiffed on a pass Wicks could have caught to move the chains. He was a bit of a let-down to me.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 21 Jan 2024 12:31
by Crazylegs Starks
Labrev wrote: ↑21 Jan 2024 12:16
Doubs dropped the TD and whiffed on a pass Wicks could have caught to move the chains. He was a bit of a let-down to me.
I didn't feel it was a drop, but rather a really good play by the defender
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 22 Jan 2024 12:20
by AmishMafia
If Savage got that pick 6 - easy choice (and we win the game)
If Anders doesn't miss the FG, I would pick him for nailing the bad snap kick.
If a defensive player would have stepped up and made a stop on that last drive . . .
I was going to go offensive line while wating in 3rd quarter. They did very well for 65% of the game against an outstanding front 7. Had they maintained we win so . . .
So I'm going Karl Brooks. Capping off an impressive rookie year by a late round pick.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 22 Jan 2024 16:55
by lulu
I was clearly thinking I was going to vote for Kenny Clark. He was all over the field, hustling on every play. But...
Nixon gave us a bit of a spark on teams, but that's about it.
Wooden blocked a kick, which was great, but nothing else stands out.
I feel like I should pick a defensive player given how ineffective the 49ers offense was, but nobody (other than Clark) really stood out for me as having an awesome day. 49ers continued to soil the sheets on their own and don't think it was due to an elevated level of defensive play.
I'm going with an unconventional pick of Aaron Jones (expectations, blah blah blah). He is the reason we were in that game. Love had an off day and our offense needed to continue to run through him. It's not his fault that (1) Tom was injured and/or (2) MLF went away from him. He was the shining star on the day.
If he isn't playing for the Packers next year, I may cry a little. What an awesome talent and even better human being.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 23 Jan 2024 16:03
by Labrev
1. DL Karl Brooks: 90.7
2. DL Kenny Clark: 79.2
3. CB Jaire Alexander: 69.8
4. OLB Rashan Gary: 66.5
5. S Anthony Johnson Jr.: 64.5
1. TE Luke Musgrave: 75.9
2. WR Romeo Doubs: 73.5
3. RG Jon Runyan Jr.: 69.0
4. RT Zach Tom: 68.3
5. RB Aaron Jones: 64.3
Oh yeah, elite grade for mah boi Brooks.
Re: Here's Johnny PLAYOFFS divisional 49ers
Posted: 24 Jan 2024 02:20
by salmar80
I'm gonna give this a couple more days.
Wilson was unfortunately picked by no one, and it's an interesting case of production spreading all over. I don't know whom to vote for at this time.
salmar80 - WR Jayden Reed
Pckfn23 - CB Jaire Alexander
lupefiasco - OLB Lucas Van Ness
paco - LB Rashan Gary
MY_TAKE - LB Quay Walker
packman114 - WR Dontayvian Wicks
Labrev - DL Karl Brooks
Cdragon - Offensive Line
YoHoChecko - DL Davante Wyatt
BF004 - WR Christian Watson
Yoop - QB Jordan Love
RingoCStarrQB - WR Romeo Doubs
Acrobat - DB/KR Keishon Nixon
AmishMafia - TE Tucker Kraft
Packfntk - RB Aaron Jones
go pack go - Kristian Welch
Crazylegs Starks - CB Carrington Valentine
Bogey - Keshawn Banks
NCF - K Anders Carlson
APB - LB Isaiah McDuffie
lulu - TE Luke Musgrave
Madcity_matt - S Darnell Savage