Packers Huddle

BSA wrote: ↑

11 May 2021 10:03

from the internet:

"The vikings hate the Packers so much, they refuse to win a Super Bowl because Vince Lombardi's name is on it..."

The Packers hate the Vikings so much they kept the Thorp trophy and kept it secret for over 25 years.

Raptorman wrote: ↑

01 Jun 2021 10:36

BSA wrote: ↑

11 May 2021 10:03

from the internet:

"The vikings hate the Packers so much, they refuse to win a Super Bowl because Vince Lombardi's name is on it..."

The Packers hate the Vikings so much they kept the Thorp trophy and kept it secret for over 25 years.

Raptorman wrote: ↑

01 Jun 2021 10:36

BSA wrote: ↑

11 May 2021 10:03

from the internet:

"The vikings hate the Packers so much, they refuse to win a Super Bowl because Vince Lombardi's name is on it..."

The Packers hate the Vikings so much they kept the Thorp trophy and kept it secret for over 25 years.

For those that don't know the story:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ed_Thorp_Memorial_Trophy wrote:In 2015, the Thorp Trophy was found to have been in the possession of the Green Bay Packers Hall of Fame Inc. instead of with the Vikings. After some research by various teams, it was discovered that, contrary to original belief, there had been only six of the individual trophies awarded to teams for their victories, with five of them coming during Joseph Carr's-then president of the league-life, and a sixth not long after his death: Those of the 1934 and 1938 New York Giants, the 1935 Detroit Lions, the 1937 Washington Redskins, and the 1936 and 1939 Green Bay Packers, along with one trophy given out to the 1961 Green Bay Packers that was first not thought to be part of the original pattern, being differently shaped than the ones originally presented.

Packers' take: https://www.packers.com/news/mystery-of ... phy-solved

Sounds like some COVID rules staying in place.

-Can return from IR after 3 weeks
-Unlimited returns from IR
-16 man PS.

I really like all 3.

BF004 wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 07:50

Sounds like some COVID rules staying in place.

-Can return from IR after 3 weeks
-Unlimited returns from IR
-16 man PS.

I really like all 3.

Me too. I never really understood the IR "all-or-nothing" approach or even the limited return policy. I get that the league wanted to discourage teams from stashing players and whatnot but the quality-of-players/play degradation with those policies far outweighed the gains.

USFL is coming back next spring. XFL is supposed to be back next spring too. Going to be interesting to see how all that works.

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 09:25

USFL is coming back next spring. XFL is supposed to be back next spring too. Going to be interesting to see how all that works.

Prediction: it doesn't work particularly well

YoHoChecko wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 09:39

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 09:25

USFL is coming back next spring. XFL is supposed to be back next spring too. Going to be interesting to see how all that works.

Prediction: it doesn't work particularly well

Bold prediction. The only way one of these ever works is if it is brought under the fold of the NFL and works as a "minor leagues" or pipeline to the NFL.

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 10:03

YoHoChecko wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 09:39

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 09:25

USFL is coming back next spring. XFL is supposed to be back next spring too. Going to be interesting to see how all that works.

Prediction: it doesn't work particularly well

Bold prediction. The only way one of these ever works is if it is brought under the fold of the NFL and works as a "minor leagues" or pipeline to the NFL.

Indeed, but the NFL owners want someone else to take the (huge) risk of founding that league, to innovate to find an audience for 2nd rate football, and to do the legwork of initially growing it. Once someone manages to build a sustainable league that at least breaks even, the NFL can swoop in, buy it and institute a minor league system.

salmar80 wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 11:46

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 10:03

YoHoChecko wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 09:39

Prediction: it doesn't work particularly well

Bold prediction. The only way one of these ever works is if it is brought under the fold of the NFL and works as a "minor leagues" or pipeline to the NFL.

Indeed, but the NFL owners want someone else to take the (huge) risk of founding that league, to innovate to find an audience for 2nd rate football, and to do the legwork of initially growing it. Once someone manages to build a sustainable league that at least breaks even, the NFL can swoop in, buy it and institute a minor league system.

I don’t think a minor league will ever be successful in American sports. No one wants to watch that. We already have college ball. Minor league baseball doesn’t make much. The G league doesn’t make much. No one wants to watch bums when you can watch the best in the NFL or the future in college which already is rooted in culturally.

lupedafiasco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 12:55

salmar80 wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 11:46

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 10:03

Bold prediction. The only way one of these ever works is if it is brought under the fold of the NFL and works as a "minor leagues" or pipeline to the NFL.

Indeed, but the NFL owners want someone else to take the (huge) risk of founding that league, to innovate to find an audience for 2nd rate football, and to do the legwork of initially growing it. Once someone manages to build a sustainable league that at least breaks even, the NFL can swoop in, buy it and institute a minor league system.

I don’t think a minor league will ever be successful in American sports. No one wants to watch that. We already have college ball. Minor league baseball doesn’t make much. The G league doesn’t make much. No one wants to watch bums when you can watch the best in the NFL or the future in college which already is rooted in culturally.

Unless that league allows players to bypass college for a year or 2, so the quality and intrigue increases a bit.

But I agree, as much as people love the NFL. A spring, or any other, football league will never be heavily watched.

lupedafiasco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 12:55

salmar80 wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 11:46

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 10:03

Bold prediction. The only way one of these ever works is if it is brought under the fold of the NFL and works as a "minor leagues" or pipeline to the NFL.

Indeed, but the NFL owners want someone else to take the (huge) risk of founding that league, to innovate to find an audience for 2nd rate football, and to do the legwork of initially growing it. Once someone manages to build a sustainable league that at least breaks even, the NFL can swoop in, buy it and institute a minor league system.

I don’t think a minor league will ever be successful in American sports. No one wants to watch that. We already have college ball. Minor league baseball doesn’t make much. The G league doesn’t make much. No one wants to watch bums when you can watch the best in the NFL or the future in college which already is rooted in culturally.

It's a tough sell for sure, and a big reason why NFL owners rather let others risk their money.

NFL Europe made some sense, as it pulled double duty as a developmental league and a marketing tool.

lupedafiasco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 12:55

salmar80 wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 11:46

paco wrote: ↑

03 Jun 2021 10:03

Bold prediction. The only way one of these ever works is if it is brought under the fold of the NFL and works as a "minor leagues" or pipeline to the NFL.

Indeed, but the NFL owners want someone else to take the (huge) risk of founding that league, to innovate to find an audience for 2nd rate football, and to do the legwork of initially growing it. Once someone manages to build a sustainable league that at least breaks even, the NFL can swoop in, buy it and institute a minor league system.

I don’t think a minor league will ever be successful in American sports. No one wants to watch that. We already have college ball. Minor league baseball doesn’t make much. The G league doesn’t make much. No one wants to watch bums when you can watch the best in the NFL or the future in college which already is rooted in culturally.

Baseball and basketball work because the venues are smaller, there are more games and you can create a fun atmosphere with smaller crowds. Minor league sports actually can do very well when placed in cities without major market teams. The Sioux Falls Skyforce in the G League for instance is very popular in Sioux Falls, SD because there is no other NBA market. In fact, no other professional market. Plus, a 3,000 to 5,000 crowd actually feels like a lot and the revenue is there because there are a lot of games and small roster sizes.

Football is a whole new animal. Even small fields are 20,000 capacity and thus look oddly empty on game day. In addition, roster sizes are too big and there are minimal games because it is hard on the body. So ticket revenue can't pay for player expenses alone which means the league needs to get TV and sponsor revenue to be competitive and pay out a decent wage.

That's just not feasible. Not enough people watch if the team isn't in the same town and large markets don't care for minor league sports like a small town does. College football is the developmental league for the NFL. The only thing that even makes business sense is Arena football. But it's such a different product than the NFL that it is hard to take it seriously.

This is someone I cannot believe is still available. I would love to make this move, but highly, highly doubt we can afford it.

JC, is it going to be fun watching this thing crash and burn.

Going to set Tim Boyle's progression back by a year.

NCF wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 12:40

JC, is it going to be fun watching this thing crash and burn.

Like 9 times out of ten, I'm in total agreement here, but I REALLY like his coaching staff. They might develop into a team in spite of him.

Though I do love Ted Lasso, glad to get that shoutout in there

YoHoChecko wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 13:43

NCF wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 12:40

JC, is it going to be fun watching this thing crash and burn.

Like 9 times out of ten, I'm in total agreement here, but I REALLY like his coaching staff. They might develop into a team in spite of him.

Though I do love Ted Lasso, glad to get that shoutout in there

And I LOVED their draft. They are building the Lions the right way. Those lines are going to be SICK. Even if they suck this year who cares. Get their QB in 2022 and this team could be amazing pretty quick.

go pak go wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 14:04

YoHoChecko wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 13:43

NCF wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 12:40

JC, is it going to be fun watching this thing crash and burn.

Like 9 times out of ten, I'm in total agreement here, but I REALLY like his coaching staff. They might develop into a team in spite of him.

Though I do love Ted Lasso, glad to get that shoutout in there

And I LOVED their draft. They are building the Lions the right way. Those lines are going to be SICK. Even if they suck this year who cares. Get their QB in 2022 and this team could be amazing pretty quick.

Any team who's plan involves starting to look for a new QB next offseason is nowhere close to amazing.

BF004 wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 14:57

go pak go wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 14:04

YoHoChecko wrote: ↑

04 Jun 2021 13:43

Like 9 times out of ten, I'm in total agreement here, but I REALLY like his coaching staff. They might develop into a team in spite of him.

Though I do love Ted Lasso, glad to get that shoutout in there

And I LOVED their draft. They are building the Lions the right way. Those lines are going to be SICK. Even if they suck this year who cares. Get their QB in 2022 and this team could be amazing pretty quick.

Any team who's plan involves starting to look for a new QB next offseason is nowhere close to amazing.

ooh I disagree. There have been plenty of teams the last 4 years or so that have jumped to amazing with QB questions going into an offseason.

2017 Vikings. 2018 to 2020 Rams. 2018 to 2020 49ers. The 2019 Bucs. The 2019 and 2020 Tennessee Titans. The Miami Dolphins.

I simply like the baseof the Lions roster. They will stink this year. But I liked their draft just like I liked the 2020 Panthers draft.