if Walker graded so high why did Nijman play? was Walker hurt?
iirc Nijman got the start but left with injury.
didn't he return later though? thought so.
Re: Week 9 Post-Game: Packers 20 Rams 3
Posted: 07 Nov 2023 10:44
by APB
Thanks for bringing the vids [mention]Pckfn23[/mention]. Hopefully [mention]lupedafiasco[/mention] unblocks you long enough to watch them and see confirmation the deep pass to Watson was indeed NOT under thrown.
Thanks for bringing the vids @Pckfn23. Hopefully @lupedafiasco unblocks you long enough to watch them and see confirmation the deep pass to Watson was indeed NOT under thrown.
see that was my point before, Lupe made a point, if where talking about the same pass if Love placed it more to the edge Watson wouldn't have had to turn around to catch the ball
I know Love is trying to place the ball where only the receiver can make the catch, he learned from a QB that mastered that art, about the only thing we see Love do different then Rodgers is the side arm zingers, everything else is copy cat Rodgers, the footwork seems identical, the prancing and dancing, all Rodgers. to me the ball placement is a Rodgers trait, and will take time to master.
Thanks for bringing the vids @Pckfn23. Hopefully @lupedafiasco unblocks you long enough to watch them and see confirmation the deep pass to Watson was indeed NOT under thrown.
see that was my point before, Lupe made a point, if where talking about the same pass if Love placed it more to the edge Watson wouldn't have had to turn around to catch the ball
Lupe specifically said it was underthrown. It was not.
Re: Week 9 Post-Game: Packers 20 Rams 3
Posted: 07 Nov 2023 11:19
by Pckfn23
Here you can see the footwork of Love. It's not good, he is set up to throw to the middle of the field and thus he throws behind Watson. Fixable.
He didn't post Bottom 5 O or D. Disappointing, those are my favorite!!
Interesting to see Wicks as high even with the fumble. IMO hes been our best WR and I think he beats out everyone for WR1 next year thats on the current roster.
Yes. Honestly if there is a potential #1 on our roster, that man is Dontraviyon Wicks. Super excited about him.
I think Watson could be a special #2 and Doubs a great #3. But Wicks has the true WR1 upside.
Thanks for bringing the vids @Pckfn23. Hopefully @lupedafiasco unblocks you long enough to watch them and see confirmation the deep pass to Watson was indeed NOT under thrown.
see that was my point before, Lupe made a point, if where talking about the same pass if Love placed it more to the edge Watson wouldn't have had to turn around to catch the ball
Lupe specifically said it was underthrown. It was not.
again farther to the side and Watson doesn't have to do anything other then just run under the catch, so again poor ball placement, point is it could have been a easier catch.
see that was my point before, Lupe made a point, if where talking about the same pass if Love placed it more to the edge Watson wouldn't have had to turn around to catch the ball
Lupe specifically said it was underthrown. It was not.
again farther to the side and Watson doesn't have to do anything other then just run under the catch, so again poor ball placement, point is it could have been a easier catch.
Correct its still a bailout catch. Terrible accuracy on this one. Either Love was trying to get it over the top in which case it was an underthrow or he threw it way to far up the field where it would have been wide open and its a significant overthrow. Either way bad down field accuracy.
As for unblocking 23 I would rather jerk off with sandpaper.
again farther to the side and Watson doesn't have to do anything other then just run under the catch, so again poor ball placement, point is it could have been a easier catch.
You are arguing a point no one is contesting. Read what I write: Lupe said the pass was underthrown. It was not.
The one Watson had to bail him out on down the field was another poorly underthrown ball.
It was also used as an example for the assertion that Love is always underthrowing balls. The point was the underthrow.
Re: Week 9 Post-Game: Packers 20 Rams 3
Posted: 07 Nov 2023 12:28
by Pckfn23
It's always interesting when one dishes it out, but can't take it...
again farther to the side and Watson doesn't have to do anything other then just run under the catch, so again poor ball placement, point is it could have been a easier catch.
You are arguing a point no one is contesting. Read what I write: Lupe said the pass was underthrown. It was not.
The one Watson had to bail him out on down the field was another poorly underthrown ball.
It was also used as an example for the assertion that Love is always underthrowing balls. The point was the underthrow.
whatever, I was also pointing out that he is trying to place the balls so only the receiver can make the catch, but in the process his throws are often to far in that direction, or to low, under thrown, these are my opinions and I should get full credit for them
Re: Week 9 Post-Game: Packers 20 Rams 3
Posted: 07 Nov 2023 12:54
by Crazylegs Starks
Seeing the play again just reinforces what I thought watching it live: It was not under-thrown, but it should have been farther toward the sideline.
Also, if Love can continue to clean up his footwork, it will help him a lot.
again farther to the side and Watson doesn't have to do anything other then just run under the catch, so again poor ball placement, point is it could have been a easier catch.
You are arguing a point no one is contesting. Read what I write: Lupe said the pass was underthrown. It was not.
The one Watson had to bail him out on down the field was another poorly underthrown ball.
It was also used as an example for the assertion that Love is always underthrowing balls. The point was the underthrow.
whatever, I was also pointing out that he is trying to place the balls so only the receiver can make the catch, but in the process his throws are often to far in that direction, or to low, under thrown, these are my opinions and I should get full credit for them
Great, then your comment had nothing to do with [mention]APB[/mention]'s post you quoted...
You are arguing a point no one is contesting. Read what I write: Lupe said the pass was underthrown. It was not.
It was also used as an example for the assertion that Love is always underthrowing balls. The point was the underthrow.
whatever, I was also pointing out that he is trying to place the balls so only the receiver can make the catch, but in the process his throws are often to far in that direction, or to low, under thrown, these are my opinions and I should get full credit for them
Great, then your comment had nothing to do with @APB's post you quoted...
it concerns everyone who said he just needs to rip it, you, APB and others touched on that, so that is my response to everyone, he learned under Rodgers and now he is trying to do the stuff Rodgers did, so even when he just flings the ball he is targeting where he's throwing it.