Fiasco Mock 1.0 Where to go from here
Posted: 27 Jan 2021 00:10
GM:
You gotta keep Gutey in there. 2 straight 13-3 years doesnt warrant a firing. That being said a close eye will need to be on his last draft class. Theyre going to need to be great this year. If youre going to draft an entire crop of backup players that offer minimal value in year 1 they better show up in year 2.
HC:
You dont fire ML. I dont care what you think of any decision made in the game yesterday. Hes one of the best offensive play callers in the entire league and has led the team to 13-3 in 2 years.
OC/DC:
Hackett stays. There seemed like there was too much clashing between LaFLeur and Pettine all year about philosophy and personnel. I think LaFleur has earned the right to bring in his own guy as a DC and I think Pettine has blundered too much as a DC to maintain his position. I'm not sure who to go with but I would really prefer a 4-3 guy. And I know most teams basically play nickel and dime now but at least in those schemes you arent asking your edge guys to cover. They can completely focus on their craft of setting the edge and rushing the passer. Ive always said I hated the 3-4. Always have and always will.
ST:
This needs to be changed. Many too many miscues. I dont know how because the Packers ST have been bad for a decade plus but this was the worst it has ever been. I dont think they ever had a consistent game. They didnt even have a consistent unit. Every aspect of STs was bad and I would be shocked if Mennenga ever gets a chance again as a coach in the NFL after this season. This was a historically bad ST performance.
Cut:
Preston Smith- I keep flip flopping on this one but the best option has to be post June 1st cut him. Incur a dead cap of 4 mil this year and next year and save 12 million now. Gary was the 12th overall pick going into year 3. He needs to be starting now. Z and Gary are the two best edge guys and Smith is in no way worth 16 million especially coming off the bench.
Christian Kirksey- Cutting Kirksey save 5.6 mil. With Barnes and Martin you have 2 options that are no only cheaper but better than Kirksey. This one is obvious.
Dean Lowry- Another post June 1st cut. It costs us 1.5 million this offseason and next but saves 4.8 mil now. Keke is a better pass rusher and Lancaster is a better run defender. Lowry just is an ok player but he really needs to be upgraded on.
Josh Jackson- The Packers signing Tramon was a clear signal the Pack are done with this guy. He save 1.3 million by cutting him. The pick had a lot of potential but he just doesnt have it.
Oren Burks- Barnes is ahead oh him. Summers is ahead of him. Im pretty confident Martin is going to be starting next season and is ahead of him. Cutting him save almost 1 mil. Just time to move on from a failed project who was getting the Datone Jones treatment moving him anywhere to see if he had some use.
Devin Funchess- I wasnt on board with the Funchess signing before. I definitely didnt like it after he opted out. Im all out on Funchess. You have Adams, Lazard, and MVS as a decent 3. You need to draft at least 2 to develop long term. I dont see how Funchess fits. Saves 1.2 mil.
Dead cap=Aprox $9.3 mil
Savings=Aprox $25.8 mil
Cap: $182.5
I dont think the cap goes down. I just cant see how the league can do that with most teams with contracts that project it going upwards. I think it will go up slightly to 205 mil and smooth out the damages over the next few years on the new TV deals.
With the post June 1st cuts the Packers have some money to work with going into camp. I think with this extra money you extend Adams. Not sure on specifics but set it up to carry money forward making it possible to resign Alexander and Jenkins.
Franchise Tag:
Aaron Jones- Its gonna be hard for players to get a long term big money deal on the market I think. Jones wants to get paid. The Packers want to keep Jones. The tag price according to OTC is 10.8 mil which is a steal. I think it is the better deal for the Packers but gives Jones a chance to score bigger next offseason as compared to this one where teams are strapped.
Players unsigned:
Corey Linsley- You cant pay everyone on the line. Linsley is a great player but we already have Bak and Turner under contract and will be looking at Jenkins soon enough. We took 3 interior players last draft. Had we not singed Turner to a dumb deal I would think its possible but with that overpay its unlikely.
Kevin King- Good riddance. Hopefully you get cooked somewhere else next year, preferably on a division rival.
Jamal Williams- Cant keep everyone. Very likeable player and I wish him the best.
Lane Taylor- Often injured and past his prime at this point in his career.
Tyler Ervin- Often injured and on the older side of RBs.
Damon Harrison- Go with a younger, cheaper option.
Montravious Adams- Not a very good or reliable player.
Resign:
Tyler Lancaster- Cheap RFA run defender.
Chandon Sullivan- Cheap RFA bargain nickel back. Great value.
Allen Lazard- Decent WR on a RFA deal. Bargain value.
Robert Tonyan- Great value for an RFA. No brainer. Might need to put a higher tender here.
Raven Greene- Cheap RFA with a lot of experience. Bargain value.
Draft:
Round 1:
Asante Samuel Jr FSU
Last mock I said it might be early to take Samuel but PFF mocked him found 1 and I saw another few sites putting him in the 1st round as well even before our pick. Hes best in a man scheme I think but PFF states that in zone he is 7th/156 prospects forcing incompletions. Samuel is on the smaller side but makes up for it with sticky coverage, athleticism, and a willingness to play hard. Hes a very willing and skilled tackler. He gives it everything he has when trying to get ball carriers down and fighting through blocks. A lot of Jaire in him when watching him attack ball carriers. His ball skills need to improve. You really would like more production but he also wasnt targeted much as FSU. I think this is the 4th best CB in terms of coverage in this class.
Round 2:
Jalen Mayfield OT Michigan
Remember this guy. I think this pick is going to be a steal. Hes definitely going to be a bit of a project because of lack of experience. Hes only a RS Sophomore. Im actually shocked he declared. He missed time this year between injuries and opting out some time but last season he took on some of the best pass rushers in the nation and held his own, most notably Chase Young. Hes definitely young and raw but super athletic and talented. With our OL coach and the tools here to work with I think this guy could be one of the best RTs in the league. It will be interesting to see if he goes earlier than this with the lack of experience and combine. Its really amazing how many good OTs are in this class. I think a an early 2nd round prospect can be found at the end of round 2 at this position.
Round 3:
Elijah Molden CB Washington
This is going to be a star nickel back I think for whoever takes him. Hes only 5'10 and has been used exclusively in the slot by Washington but this dude is a playmaker. He can do it all. Hes got instincts, sticky in man, explosive in zone, and a fighter in the run game. Hes got the ability to blitz to. Obviously size is a limitation but its not as important in the slot. This guy is a chess piece. He ran a 4.51 in high school so he probably mid 4.4s now. His father was a player and the Washington coach was an NFL DB coach. Theres also a lot of flexibility to play some S here as well.
Round 4a:
Tamorrion Terry WR FSU
Ive kept Terry in my mocks and I think he will probably stay in them. Hes just so dangerous getting behind defenses. I think this is probably where he belongs. Elite athletes with production issues usually go in the middle rounds. Terry pretty much is a better MVS. Let him develop a year behind the current crop and hope he can gain some consistency in his hands and become a better route runner. He is a project. A lot of his reception are just go routes and screens. This DK Metcalf minus the body. Hes 6'4 and likely runs in the low 4.4s. Maybe even high 4.3. Hes also very dangerous with the ball in his hands. For a big receiver he is very elusive. He can be a game breaker with the ball in space.
Round 4b:
Chubba Hubbard RB Oklahoma St
To be honest this is a really bad RB class. Its got some decent players but for the most part I'm not impressed. Hubbard is kind of a jack of all trades player. Think somewhere between Brandon Jackson and Jamal Williams. As a pass blocker I think hes one of the better ones in this class. He doesnt have break away speed, he isnt a big or powerful back, hes not the most elusive, and hes a solid receiver. Hes really just a good all around player. Hes definitely a vision runner. He makes good reads, patient, and will get consistent yards. I really think he ends up being one of those good RBs who is never going to be the bellcow but can be a really good option to give the bell cow a break.
Round 5a:
Damonte Coaxie WR Memphis
Another bigger receiver at 6'3 like Gutey likes. This guy is another sleeper I think. Very productive player although Memphis does run a receiver friendly scheme. Hes got a good combination of size, speed, and strength but he isnt going to take the top off a defense. He has realy good hands, understands how to win 50/50 balls using his size. Hes one of the better bail out receivers in this class I think. Pretty solid blocker for a young player. I would say hes one of those Lazard/Sanu type players with maybe a little more upside. Im confident this guy ends up being at the very worst a solid player.
Round 5b:
Bobby Brown DT Texas A&M
This could be a steal. This could be the next Montravious Adams. Every single scouting report mentions his lack of effort and motor. I typically dont like that but its the compensatory pick in round 5 and when you watch this guy play hard he is dominant. Hes the space eater of the A&M defense. He would come into the league as a very good rotational run defender. If a coach is ever able to motivate him to plkay hard down in and down out you have a monster. All reports say the effort level dips on the field. Hes a gym rat. 6'4 and 315 but he doesnt look like a fat boy. Hes also got a nice first step and short area quickness for a player his size. I think he would be an upgrade over Lancaster in every facet. Motor issues shouldnt come into play as a rotational player. Injured himself celebrating which was hilarious.
Round 6a:
Tarron Jackson Edge Coastal Carolina
Another potential steal. His short comings are his length and not being an elite athlete. He has been very productive as a pass rusher and the dude is strong. He plays to his strengths for sure. Hes uses his lack of length to improve his leverage getting lower than lineman and uses his power to get linemans momentum against them when rushing. He does well to set the edge as well.
Round 6b:
Dan Moore Jr OT Texas A&M
LT for Texas A&M. I think hes actually a pretty solid player. Nothing spectacular but I think theres potential here. With a better QB the whole A&M offense would have been better. Kellen Mond sucked. Hes definitely a good run blocker. Pass blocking is fine with his length but he lacks athleticism. Like I said this is a really deep OT class. This guy could probably be a 4th round pick in a class that isnt stacked.
Round 7:
Brady Breeze S Oregon
I like his name.
Depth Chart:
QB:
A Godgers
J Love
T Boyle
RB:
A Jones
A Dillon
C Hubbard
FB:
TE:
R Tonyan
J Deguara
J Sternberger
D Dafney
WR:
D Adams
A Lazard
MVS
ESB
T Terry
D Coxie
OT:
D Bak
Mayfield
R Wagner
D Moore
OG:
B Turner
L Patrick
J Runyan
S Stepaniak
C:
E Jenkins
J Hanson
ED:
Z Smith
R Gary
J Garvin
T Jackson
IDL:
K Clark
K Keke
T Lancaster
B Brown
LB:
K Barnes
K Martin
T Summers
CB:
J Alexander
A Samuel
C Sullivan
K Hollman
E Molden
S:
A Amos
D Savage
R Greene
V Scott
B Breeze
LS:
H Bradley
K:
M Crosby
P:
J Scott
Room for 3 UDFAs. Maybe hold over a CB and ILB from last year. Find a return specialist somewhere.
You gotta keep Gutey in there. 2 straight 13-3 years doesnt warrant a firing. That being said a close eye will need to be on his last draft class. Theyre going to need to be great this year. If youre going to draft an entire crop of backup players that offer minimal value in year 1 they better show up in year 2.
HC:
You dont fire ML. I dont care what you think of any decision made in the game yesterday. Hes one of the best offensive play callers in the entire league and has led the team to 13-3 in 2 years.
OC/DC:
Hackett stays. There seemed like there was too much clashing between LaFLeur and Pettine all year about philosophy and personnel. I think LaFleur has earned the right to bring in his own guy as a DC and I think Pettine has blundered too much as a DC to maintain his position. I'm not sure who to go with but I would really prefer a 4-3 guy. And I know most teams basically play nickel and dime now but at least in those schemes you arent asking your edge guys to cover. They can completely focus on their craft of setting the edge and rushing the passer. Ive always said I hated the 3-4. Always have and always will.
ST:
This needs to be changed. Many too many miscues. I dont know how because the Packers ST have been bad for a decade plus but this was the worst it has ever been. I dont think they ever had a consistent game. They didnt even have a consistent unit. Every aspect of STs was bad and I would be shocked if Mennenga ever gets a chance again as a coach in the NFL after this season. This was a historically bad ST performance.
Cut:
Preston Smith- I keep flip flopping on this one but the best option has to be post June 1st cut him. Incur a dead cap of 4 mil this year and next year and save 12 million now. Gary was the 12th overall pick going into year 3. He needs to be starting now. Z and Gary are the two best edge guys and Smith is in no way worth 16 million especially coming off the bench.
Christian Kirksey- Cutting Kirksey save 5.6 mil. With Barnes and Martin you have 2 options that are no only cheaper but better than Kirksey. This one is obvious.
Dean Lowry- Another post June 1st cut. It costs us 1.5 million this offseason and next but saves 4.8 mil now. Keke is a better pass rusher and Lancaster is a better run defender. Lowry just is an ok player but he really needs to be upgraded on.
Josh Jackson- The Packers signing Tramon was a clear signal the Pack are done with this guy. He save 1.3 million by cutting him. The pick had a lot of potential but he just doesnt have it.
Oren Burks- Barnes is ahead oh him. Summers is ahead of him. Im pretty confident Martin is going to be starting next season and is ahead of him. Cutting him save almost 1 mil. Just time to move on from a failed project who was getting the Datone Jones treatment moving him anywhere to see if he had some use.
Devin Funchess- I wasnt on board with the Funchess signing before. I definitely didnt like it after he opted out. Im all out on Funchess. You have Adams, Lazard, and MVS as a decent 3. You need to draft at least 2 to develop long term. I dont see how Funchess fits. Saves 1.2 mil.
Dead cap=Aprox $9.3 mil
Savings=Aprox $25.8 mil
Cap: $182.5
I dont think the cap goes down. I just cant see how the league can do that with most teams with contracts that project it going upwards. I think it will go up slightly to 205 mil and smooth out the damages over the next few years on the new TV deals.
With the post June 1st cuts the Packers have some money to work with going into camp. I think with this extra money you extend Adams. Not sure on specifics but set it up to carry money forward making it possible to resign Alexander and Jenkins.
Franchise Tag:
Aaron Jones- Its gonna be hard for players to get a long term big money deal on the market I think. Jones wants to get paid. The Packers want to keep Jones. The tag price according to OTC is 10.8 mil which is a steal. I think it is the better deal for the Packers but gives Jones a chance to score bigger next offseason as compared to this one where teams are strapped.
Players unsigned:
Corey Linsley- You cant pay everyone on the line. Linsley is a great player but we already have Bak and Turner under contract and will be looking at Jenkins soon enough. We took 3 interior players last draft. Had we not singed Turner to a dumb deal I would think its possible but with that overpay its unlikely.
Kevin King- Good riddance. Hopefully you get cooked somewhere else next year, preferably on a division rival.
Jamal Williams- Cant keep everyone. Very likeable player and I wish him the best.
Lane Taylor- Often injured and past his prime at this point in his career.
Tyler Ervin- Often injured and on the older side of RBs.
Damon Harrison- Go with a younger, cheaper option.
Montravious Adams- Not a very good or reliable player.
Resign:
Tyler Lancaster- Cheap RFA run defender.
Chandon Sullivan- Cheap RFA bargain nickel back. Great value.
Allen Lazard- Decent WR on a RFA deal. Bargain value.
Robert Tonyan- Great value for an RFA. No brainer. Might need to put a higher tender here.
Raven Greene- Cheap RFA with a lot of experience. Bargain value.
Draft:
Round 1:
Asante Samuel Jr FSU
Last mock I said it might be early to take Samuel but PFF mocked him found 1 and I saw another few sites putting him in the 1st round as well even before our pick. Hes best in a man scheme I think but PFF states that in zone he is 7th/156 prospects forcing incompletions. Samuel is on the smaller side but makes up for it with sticky coverage, athleticism, and a willingness to play hard. Hes a very willing and skilled tackler. He gives it everything he has when trying to get ball carriers down and fighting through blocks. A lot of Jaire in him when watching him attack ball carriers. His ball skills need to improve. You really would like more production but he also wasnt targeted much as FSU. I think this is the 4th best CB in terms of coverage in this class.
Round 2:
Jalen Mayfield OT Michigan
Remember this guy. I think this pick is going to be a steal. Hes definitely going to be a bit of a project because of lack of experience. Hes only a RS Sophomore. Im actually shocked he declared. He missed time this year between injuries and opting out some time but last season he took on some of the best pass rushers in the nation and held his own, most notably Chase Young. Hes definitely young and raw but super athletic and talented. With our OL coach and the tools here to work with I think this guy could be one of the best RTs in the league. It will be interesting to see if he goes earlier than this with the lack of experience and combine. Its really amazing how many good OTs are in this class. I think a an early 2nd round prospect can be found at the end of round 2 at this position.
Round 3:
Elijah Molden CB Washington
This is going to be a star nickel back I think for whoever takes him. Hes only 5'10 and has been used exclusively in the slot by Washington but this dude is a playmaker. He can do it all. Hes got instincts, sticky in man, explosive in zone, and a fighter in the run game. Hes got the ability to blitz to. Obviously size is a limitation but its not as important in the slot. This guy is a chess piece. He ran a 4.51 in high school so he probably mid 4.4s now. His father was a player and the Washington coach was an NFL DB coach. Theres also a lot of flexibility to play some S here as well.
Round 4a:
Tamorrion Terry WR FSU
Ive kept Terry in my mocks and I think he will probably stay in them. Hes just so dangerous getting behind defenses. I think this is probably where he belongs. Elite athletes with production issues usually go in the middle rounds. Terry pretty much is a better MVS. Let him develop a year behind the current crop and hope he can gain some consistency in his hands and become a better route runner. He is a project. A lot of his reception are just go routes and screens. This DK Metcalf minus the body. Hes 6'4 and likely runs in the low 4.4s. Maybe even high 4.3. Hes also very dangerous with the ball in his hands. For a big receiver he is very elusive. He can be a game breaker with the ball in space.
Round 4b:
Chubba Hubbard RB Oklahoma St
To be honest this is a really bad RB class. Its got some decent players but for the most part I'm not impressed. Hubbard is kind of a jack of all trades player. Think somewhere between Brandon Jackson and Jamal Williams. As a pass blocker I think hes one of the better ones in this class. He doesnt have break away speed, he isnt a big or powerful back, hes not the most elusive, and hes a solid receiver. Hes really just a good all around player. Hes definitely a vision runner. He makes good reads, patient, and will get consistent yards. I really think he ends up being one of those good RBs who is never going to be the bellcow but can be a really good option to give the bell cow a break.
Round 5a:
Damonte Coaxie WR Memphis
Another bigger receiver at 6'3 like Gutey likes. This guy is another sleeper I think. Very productive player although Memphis does run a receiver friendly scheme. Hes got a good combination of size, speed, and strength but he isnt going to take the top off a defense. He has realy good hands, understands how to win 50/50 balls using his size. Hes one of the better bail out receivers in this class I think. Pretty solid blocker for a young player. I would say hes one of those Lazard/Sanu type players with maybe a little more upside. Im confident this guy ends up being at the very worst a solid player.
Round 5b:
Bobby Brown DT Texas A&M
This could be a steal. This could be the next Montravious Adams. Every single scouting report mentions his lack of effort and motor. I typically dont like that but its the compensatory pick in round 5 and when you watch this guy play hard he is dominant. Hes the space eater of the A&M defense. He would come into the league as a very good rotational run defender. If a coach is ever able to motivate him to plkay hard down in and down out you have a monster. All reports say the effort level dips on the field. Hes a gym rat. 6'4 and 315 but he doesnt look like a fat boy. Hes also got a nice first step and short area quickness for a player his size. I think he would be an upgrade over Lancaster in every facet. Motor issues shouldnt come into play as a rotational player. Injured himself celebrating which was hilarious.
Round 6a:
Tarron Jackson Edge Coastal Carolina
Another potential steal. His short comings are his length and not being an elite athlete. He has been very productive as a pass rusher and the dude is strong. He plays to his strengths for sure. Hes uses his lack of length to improve his leverage getting lower than lineman and uses his power to get linemans momentum against them when rushing. He does well to set the edge as well.
Round 6b:
Dan Moore Jr OT Texas A&M
LT for Texas A&M. I think hes actually a pretty solid player. Nothing spectacular but I think theres potential here. With a better QB the whole A&M offense would have been better. Kellen Mond sucked. Hes definitely a good run blocker. Pass blocking is fine with his length but he lacks athleticism. Like I said this is a really deep OT class. This guy could probably be a 4th round pick in a class that isnt stacked.
Round 7:
Brady Breeze S Oregon
I like his name.
Depth Chart:
QB:
A Godgers
J Love
T Boyle
RB:
A Jones
A Dillon
C Hubbard
FB:
TE:
R Tonyan
J Deguara
J Sternberger
D Dafney
WR:
D Adams
A Lazard
MVS
ESB
T Terry
D Coxie
OT:
D Bak
Mayfield
R Wagner
D Moore
OG:
B Turner
L Patrick
J Runyan
S Stepaniak
C:
E Jenkins
J Hanson
ED:
Z Smith
R Gary
J Garvin
T Jackson
IDL:
K Clark
K Keke
T Lancaster
B Brown
LB:
K Barnes
K Martin
T Summers
CB:
J Alexander
A Samuel
C Sullivan
K Hollman
E Molden
S:
A Amos
D Savage
R Greene
V Scott
B Breeze
LS:
H Bradley
K:
M Crosby
P:
J Scott
Room for 3 UDFAs. Maybe hold over a CB and ILB from last year. Find a return specialist somewhere.