Page 1 of 1

2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 25 Apr 2022 10:56
by BF004
Brought it back again this year, was really popular in 2020, not so much last year.

I'm sitting at 34 first round grades this year, more than I've had that I can remember. I plan on focusing a lot more on that 25-75 range this week, so that might change.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing




Let's see a few boards!

[mention]British[/mention], you gunna make McGinn's again if you can find it? :)

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 25 Apr 2022 11:05
by paco
I sadly, have accidentally deleted my draft boards of the last few years. But definitely have one again this year. I stand right now at 23 1st round grades. But it probably should be closer to 30. There are several on that edge that I'd be fine with at 28 but I technically have a 2nd grade on them.

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 25 Apr 2022 11:11
by BF004
paco wrote:
25 Apr 2022 11:05
I sadly, have accidentally deleted my draft boards of the last few years. But definitely have one again this year. I stand right now at 23 1st round grades. But it probably should be closer to 30. There are several on that edge that I'd be fine with at 28 but I technically have a 2nd grade on them.
I don't see one from you last year, but your 2020 is in that spreadsheet.

image.png
image.png (84.01 KiB) Viewed 355 times

Not very high on Jordan Love, AJ Dillon or Josiah Daguara I see. :lol:

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 25 Apr 2022 11:29
by paco
BF004 wrote:
25 Apr 2022 11:11
paco wrote:
25 Apr 2022 11:05
I sadly, have accidentally deleted my draft boards of the last few years. But definitely have one again this year. I stand right now at 23 1st round grades. But it probably should be closer to 30. There are several on that edge that I'd be fine with at 28 but I technically have a 2nd grade on them.
I don't see one from you last year, but your 2020 is in that spreadsheet.


image.png


Not very high on Jordan Love, AJ Dillon or Josiah Daguara I see. :lol:
I think 2020 was the first year I did a big board like that. Still don't know what I'm doing! Not sure I really knew who Deguara was. I'm never high on RBs or do much work on them. I'm pretty sure I was like most a downgraded QB not thinking we'd take one in the 1st.

That's the way I tend to do it. I'll devalue a position I don't think we'll grab, which is why I have no 1st round QB or RB this year.

BTW, my board is not a clear representation of preference based on order. Haven't cleaned that up yet, and may not. Just names in a list in each area mostly.

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 25 Apr 2022 11:30
by BF004
Yeah, I go back and forth between making a generic board and making a Packer specific board. Maybe I'll make both.

Kind of like to look back and see how I had QB's ranked and such, which are always worthless on a Packer board.

But then also like to know who I think the Packers should be taking when they are up.


And yes, I also have no clue what I'm doing.

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 25 Apr 2022 11:38
by paco
BF004 wrote:
25 Apr 2022 11:30
Yeah, I go back and forth between making a generic board and making a Packer specific board. Maybe I'll make both.

Kind of like to look back and see how I had QB's ranked and such, which are always worthless on a Packer board.

But then also like to know who I think the Packers should be taking when they are up.


And yes, I also have no clue what I'm doing.
Yep, i really need to make both or stick with 1 concept. Mine's a combo (though mostly Packers) and I have to rely on memory what I think about each guy. And that's a dangerous thing. I added a few notes like INJ or Age to recall which I had concerns about for those reasons.

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 25 Apr 2022 21:20
by BF004
[mention]Backthepack4ever[/mention], Love it!!! Always like seeing someone get really excited about someone a little off the general narrative.

image.png
image.png (31.34 KiB) Viewed 320 times

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 26 Apr 2022 04:40
by Backthepack4ever
Thanks. I see Jones as another Kenny Clark. He's going to dominate soon. I like Davis but for 15 snaps a game I don't see the impact. Crazy athlete but Jones will be the cream of this class.

Boarding the plane to Vegas. Y'all enjoy the draft I'll pop in slightly intoxicated this week

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 26 Apr 2022 09:20
by NCF
BF004 wrote:
25 Apr 2022 11:11
Not very high on Jordan Love, AJ Dillon or Josiah Daguara I see.
I really don't remember liking Tua, at all. I guess that is where groupthink sets in. I had Love top-14 in that class, though, and in a higher tier than Justin Herbert who I distinctly remember not liking.

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 26 Apr 2022 09:24
by Yoop
NCF wrote:
26 Apr 2022 09:20
BF004 wrote:
25 Apr 2022 11:11
Not very high on Jordan Love, AJ Dillon or Josiah Daguara I see.
I really don't remember liking Tua, at all. I guess that is where groupthink sets in. I had Love top-14 in that class, though, and in a higher tier than Justin Herbert who I distinctly remember not liking.
QB follies, impossible to look inside a players head, and the QB position is mostly a head game, I've fallen for a lot of QB's over the years and to be honest missed on most of them, more then even DT's :rotf:

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 26 Apr 2022 17:39
by British
BF004 wrote:
25 Apr 2022 10:56
Brought it back again this year, was really popular in 2020, not so much last year.

I'm sitting at 34 first round grades this year, more than I've had that I can remember. I plan on focusing a lot more on that 25-75 range this week, so that might change.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing




Let's see a few boards!

@British, you gunna make McGinn's again if you can find it? :)
I've decided against McGinn's as a) his round tiers are little less uniform and b) I don't think he writes for the Athletic anymore and I'm not a subscriber at Go Long (Ty Dunne's new thing where McGinn writes) so don't have access to his stuff.

But I've done an updated version of the Brugler tiers instead.

Hopefully the key explains the data but it covers age, whether they had a visit in Green Bay etc.

The 'Underrated WRAPS' bit refers a metric which combines RAS with WROPS, a college WR production metric. More info here:

https://www.acmepackingcompany.com/nfl- ... -and-wraps

https://www.acmepackingcompany.com/nfl- ... ure-austin

Re: 2022 Make Your Own Big Board

Posted: 26 Apr 2022 21:34
by BF004
Backthepack4ever wrote:
26 Apr 2022 04:40
Thanks. I see Jones as another Kenny Clark. He's going to dominate soon. I like Davis but for 15 snaps a game I don't see the impact. Crazy athlete but Jones will be the cream of this class.

Boarding the plane to Vegas. Y'all enjoy the draft I'll pop in slightly intoxicated this week