Packers Huddle

Yeah, no standouts. Just about every pick has a negative.

Going to go with Quay. Consistent strong play throughout the game as opposed to one impressive play.

I think I'll go Ford. Had the splash play to open things up and didn't see anything egregious from him afterwards. That, and he definitely fits the underdog mold.

Rudy Ford gets my vote.

Doubs gets my vote. I picked Doubs. Doubs averaged over 10 yards per catch.

Despite the late game penalty on Quay, I think he had a hell of a game. Was all over the field, hitting hard. After last year I wasn't expecting much from Quay so my expecations coming into the season were low/measured for him. Glad he's turned it up.

My vote is for Quay,

Quay

We may need to start picking 2 players. One for the unsung hero and the other for worst player in case we have more games where they all suck!

I have half a mind to go Carlson because he was perfect and his kickoffs were better too.

But the 19 tackles for Quay is too many to pass up. I thought he played aggressive all night.

Quay

AmishMafia wrote: ↑

29 Sep 2023 06:11

Yeah, no standouts. Just about every pick has a negative.

Going to go with Quay. Consistent strong play throughout the game as opposed to one impressive play.

doubs was 9-13 targeted catches for 93 yrds, that at least deserves moderate attention

Walker continues to impress and also confuse with his impulsive aggressiveness, double digit tackles again and also a game changing penalty

I don't think Doubs had any negative plays, and his production led the team.

IMHO that makes Doubs the shinning star this week.

Yoop wrote: ↑

30 Sep 2023 06:40

AmishMafia wrote: ↑

29 Sep 2023 06:11

Yeah, no standouts. Just about every pick has a negative.

Going to go with Quay. Consistent strong play throughout the game as opposed to one impressive play.

doubs was 9-13 targeted catches for 93 yrds, that at least deserves moderate attention

Walker continues to impress and also confuse with his impulsive aggressiveness, double digit tackles again and also a game changing penalty

I don't think Doubs had any negative plays, and his production led the team.

IMHO that makes Doubs the shinning star this week.

You mean you guys don't think my offensive line should get consideration?

go pak go wrote: ↑

30 Sep 2023 09:24

You mean you guys don't think my offensive line should get consideration?

NO, but I would consider Earth, Wind, and Fire, as our OL replacements, just maybe defenders would stop beating up on our guys to take a listen, I'am willing to look at any and all alternatives

go pak go wrote: ↑

30 Sep 2023 09:24

You mean you guys don't think my offensive line should get consideration?

Consideration for the waiver wire maybe...

RingoCStarrQB wrote: ↑

29 Sep 2023 13:25

Doubs gets my vote. I picked Doubs.

Hey... follow the rules, mister!

go pak go wrote: ↑

30 Sep 2023 09:24

You mean you guys don't think my offensive line should get consideration?

Maybe the greatest quote in NFL history:

Reporter: "What do you think of your offensive line's execution?"

Bum Phillips: "I'm all for it."

After taking in a satisfactory amount of post-game info, I vote Reed.

I'll go with Quay a well. Rudy Ford looked like the early favorite for it but Quay was so consistent throughout.

Going Ford. Quay getting a lot of downfield cleanup tackles and a dumb penalty that gives up more points doesn’t really cut it for me.

lake shark wrote: ↑

04 Oct 2023 09:59

Going Ford. Quay getting a lot of downfield cleanup tackles and a dumb penalty that gives up more points doesn’t really cut it for me.

Personally, I can't really hold the penalty against him. I don't even think the refs caught it and it was wired in from the eye in the sky in NY central command and they dropped the flag well after the play happened. I know I didn't catch it and once they called it, I vaguely recalled it was a rule. I'd bet many of us are in that same boat.

But overall, he wasn't just cleaning up, he was everywhere and intense.

Brooks got a sack and deflected a ball.

Cdragon wrote: ↑

04 Oct 2023 16:03

Brooks got a sack and deflected a ball.

Considering that he is a late round rookie draft pick, that is damn good, and fits the qualifications for the winner. I will change my vote from Ford to Brooks.