Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Zach Tom (27%) [ +13 ] 5. Kenny Clark (33%) [ -1 ] 6. Xavier McKinney (35%) [FA] 7. Elgton Jenkins (47%) [ -1 ] 8. Josh Jacobs (43%) [FA] 9. Jayden Reed (36%) [ +18 ] 10T. Christ...

I'm also going to start voting for Marshawn Lloyd sooner than the rest of the board, but that's a topic for like a week or three from now. Certainly ahead of AJ Dillon, who I also like more than most of y'all but don't understand why he's on the voting list already. The initial list is the top 20 o...

Did away with the runoffs a couple years back, its better to just let ties be ties. Going to go Wyatt and LVN here. Our DL was the strength of our team much of last year, no reason to think they'll be anything but better going into this year. I could be persuaded to vote Walker as well. He makes imp...

Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Zach Tom (27%) [ +13 ] 5. Kenny Clark (33%) [ -1 ] 6. Xavier McKinney (35%) [FA] 7. Elgton Jenkins (47%) [ -1 ] 8. Josh Jacobs (43%) [FA] 9. Jayden Reed (36%) [ +18 ] 10T. Christ...

I didn't put a vote on Smith for the same reasons y'all are mentioning. I think by the end of the season it'll look silly to have Smith ahead of LVN. LVN can play, not sure how high his ceiling is but I've seen enough to say that his floor is a starting caliber player.

Sorry about the break, I had to do some travel for work. Lots of ways to go here. Already into double digits, almost to the bottom half of the starters. :shock: Wicks and ??? Smith - player on the decline, but previously worth this spot. Wyatt - player on the rise, felt like he made some impactful p...

Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Zach Tom (27%) [ +13 ] 5. Kenny Clark (33%) [ -1 ] 6. Xavier McKinney (35%) [FA] 7. Elgton Jenkins (47%) [ -1 ] 8. Josh Jacobs (43%) [FA] 9. Jayden Reed (36%) [ +18 ] 10. Current...

Reed is my next pick here. Kind of a toss up for the 2nd, either Smith or Wicks, went with Smith.

Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Zach Tom (27%) [ +13 ] 5. Kenny Clark (33%) [ -1 ] 6. Xavier McKinney (35%) [FA] 7. Elgton Jenkins (47%) [ -1 ] 8. Josh Jacobs (43%) [FA] 9. Current (xx%) [--] Percent of vote th...

I have a single vote on Jacobs, haven't used another. I expect the idea is he'll be an even bigger part of the offense than Jones was, in which case next year we're talking top 5, does he belong on the blue tier.

Wicks added by popular demand. I really think WR's should be getting votes, but I'm just not sure which one. Reed seems the most electric, most likely to do something with it. Ranking the WR's by 2023 catch %: Reed - 68.1 Wicks - 67.2 Melton - 66.7 Heath - 62.5 Doubs - 61.5 Watson - 52.8 Toure - 44....

Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Zach Tom (27%) [ +13 ] 5. Kenny Clark (33%) [ -1 ] 6. Xavier McKinney (35%) [FA] 7. Elgton Jenkins (47%) [ -1 ] 8. Current (xx%) [--] Percent of vote the winner got will be in pa...

At #6 McKinney is the highest a FA has ever gone in this. There have been a few that went #7, but never higher.
2014 - Peppers
2017 - Bennet
2018 - Graham
2019 - Z Smith

My picks today are going to be Reed for top pick and Jenkins for my second.

Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Zach Tom (27%) [ +13 ] 5. Kenny Clark (33%) [ -1 ] 6. Xavier McKinney (35%) [FA] 7. Current (xx%) [--] Percent of vote the winner got will be in parenthesis, position change vs. ...

Y'all have me sold on Reed vs. Watson, Reed is going to be my #1 pick today.

#2 will go to McKinney.

Next poll I'll add the rds 1-2 rookies.

Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Zach Tom (27%) [ +13 ] 5. Kenny Clark (33%) [ -1 ] 6. Current (xx%) [--] Percent of vote the winner got will be in parenthesis, position change vs. 2023 will be in brackets. Here...

In contrast to previous years, I'm going to change things up and do polls on the weekend. My schedule has changed since I first started this, I have some time on the weekends. I went Clark first then Watson. Clark is still one of the best DT's in the league when he's on, the maturing of the guys nex...

It looks like things are following the typical tier pattern, where big drops in % of vote indicate a new tier. It seems like there are a lot of guys that belong on this one. The blue chip (+QB) tier is lighter than it has been, its usually 4 players deep (QB+3), peaking in 2020 at 6 (7?) players dee...

I'm kind of stumped on this one, going to listen to arguments.

Leaning Clark and Watson but I definitely could be convinced to go Jenkins, Tom, Walker, Jacobs, or McKinney

Rank The Roster: 2024 Edition 1. Jordan Love (53%) [ +8 ] 2. Rashan Gary (36%) [ +3 ] 3. Jaire Alexander (48%) [ -2 ] 4. Current (xx%) [--] Percent of vote the winner got will be in parenthesis, position change vs. 2023 will be in brackets. Here's how this works: Each day there is a new thread/poll...