I don't need elite, I need good enough to win it all. Hurts isn't elite but he got the job done for PHI. Very few QBs have ever been in Burts situation where every single player on offense across the board is a great player. Sure Hurts isn’t elite but his offense has no weak links and his defense k...

I think he is still good. Injury took a big toll on him, but he was showing signs of being his old self over the 2nd half of last season. Age hasn't hit him too hard yet. The bigger thing for him is the same problem he had while he was here, which is that he requires some sort of jedi mind meld offe...

I have recently been critical of BG for his drafting, but I am equally laudatory about his FA track record. He usually does a good job on this type of player, so I expect that this will be a good signing. And in cases where his FAs have not worked out, they've been easy to jettison without much pena...

I am fine with just drafting a WR. I was in favor of not getting any new WRs last offseason, but the unit regressed so now it's time to shake things up a bit

Pckfn23 wrote: ↑

23 Feb 2025 21:01

Also wasn't Slaton like the #1 DL in the entire league at run-stopping

For all of the malignment over our pass rush up front, the run stopping did seem pretty elite.

Not a top 5 team imo. All of our analytics will be bolstered because our team was built to beat up on the bad teams. I've heard the argument that our defensive scheme is better against bad QBs, which led to us completely shutting down several teams this year while getting torched by good offenses. I...

As for the Rodgers deal I have said this multiple times. If you had the conviction to take Love you needed to stand by that pick and just move on with Love. I still believe that was a bad pick given the circumstances of where this team was and how close they were to winning in all but the minute Gu...

I think Love is the guy. I think he has elite arm talent. He was battling nagging injuries all year, his WRs completely let him down, and he was still good. His main problems are 1) too many boneheaded throws into triple coverage; 2) doesn't run the ball enough. Neither of these problems are ones th...

There is more than GM player acquisition in play here. How about coaching? It really is an important factor. I think our success has been largely due to coaching. We're just not that talented. Even in 2020/2021 our roster wasn't that great but MLF made us into a #1 seed. Unfortunately, most of the ...

As for the Rodgers deal I have said this multiple times. If you had the conviction to take Love you needed to stand by that pick and just move on with Love. I still believe that was a bad pick given the circumstances of where this team was and how close they were to winning in all but the minute Gu...

Idk, maybe it was the result of 15 years of watching duds at RB, but to me Aaron Jones seemed more elusive and explosive. I was a fan for the entirety of Green's career but I could be misremembering him a little bit. At the time I remembering thinking of him as RB5-10 (except for 2003), whereas with...

As to say that’s his only flaw I think he makes some really poor choices in giving players contracts outside of 2nd contracts. Jimmy Graham, Preston Smith, Kenny Clark, Devondre Campbell, Aaron Rodgers, then not paying Adams… the only one actually deserving. He’s gotta clean that up and make better...

I legitimately don't think there were many redeeming qualities of the entire Sherman era. You could list guys like Kampman or Sharper or KGB but I really don't think any player during that era was elite in the ways that some of these other guys were. Kampman would be the one that I would maybe incl...

Luckily, BG has done a great job of overall roster construction and he hired a tremendous coach. He did well on the most important pick. This does not change my overall optimism regarding the youngest team in the league for 2 years (and the only youngest team in the league to make the playoffs of t...

The point is, I am somewhat close to joining @lupedafiasco in calling him Gutenbumst. I'm not there yet because we have seemingly a really bright future, but I look at our roster and I just get the feeling that Gutekunst is an underwhelming drafter. He knocked it out of the park with Jaire. Love is...

Jordan can play really well, Jordan can be too lax/lazy/undisciplined at other times and look pretty poor. What is he? He still needs to determine that. He's not been elite IMO. Elite guys have a handful of passes every game nobody but elite qb's can make, the rest are just separated by timing and ...

Rodgers is probably the best player I have seen, him or Reggie White, although Reggie White played right around the time I began watching football so I couldn't really appreciate his ability as much as I could now. When it comes to passing the football, Rodgers is the best QB ever. That being said, ...

https://x.com/JayGlazer/status/1888659312526127389?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Etweet Oh my gawd and the Vikings could use a stop gap quarterback.... I don't know if Rodgers could do that. Favre obviously wanted to stick it to us, but I think Rodgers still feels like he is a Pack...

Wow, I am happy that he got in. I didn't think he would, based on what I remember of Shannon Sharpe's speech, I thought it was pretty much off the table